[xiph-rtp] Updated Speex I-D

Discussion:

Phil Kerr

2005-08-27 20:07:25 UTC

Dear all,

An updated Speex I-D is available.

http://www.plus24.com/xiph/draft-ietf-avt-rtp-speex-00.xml
http://www.plus24.com/xiph/draft-ietf-avt-rtp-speex-00.txt

As directed by the AVT Chairs this version should be submitted as a WG
document to the IETF.

Changes over the last version are based on feedback on the AVT list,
2005-04-12, with the biggest change the removal of the ITU specific
sections as the IETF feel this is not suitable for inclusion in an I-D.
Colin Perkins suggested this section be hosted on the Speex website and
a copy, which can be reformatted to suit, can be found here:

http://www.plus24.com/xiph/speex_itu.html

Regards

Phil

Jean-Marc Valin

2005-10-06 21:59:56 UTC

Permalink

Hi Phil,

The speex rtp draft is about to expire and we should re-sumbit it. I
looked at http://www.plus24.com/xiph/draft-ietf-avt-rtp-speex-00.txt and
I see a few things that should be changed:

- Section 7, 2nd paragraph: "Speex codecs [7] are able to detect the the
bitrate from the payload" should remove one "the".
- My email is listed (twice) as jean-***@hermes.usherb.ca. Could
you change it to jean-***@usherbrooke.ca (the hermes is no longer
valid)
- Please are reference to the "penh" parameter. It's doesn't belong to
the RTP draft.

Otherwise, I think we're ready for WG.

Cheers,

Jean-Marc

Post by Phil Kerr
Dear all,
An updated Speex I-D is available.
http://www.plus24.com/xiph/draft-ietf-avt-rtp-speex-00.xml
http://www.plus24.com/xiph/draft-ietf-avt-rtp-speex-00.txt
As directed by the AVT Chairs this version should be submitted as a WG
document to the IETF.
Changes over the last version are based on feedback on the AVT list,
2005-04-12, with the biggest change the removal of the ITU specific
sections as the IETF feel this is not suitable for inclusion in an I-D.
Colin Perkins suggested this section be hosted on the Speex website and
http://www.plus24.com/xiph/speex_itu.html
Regards
Phil
_______________________________________________
xiph-rtp mailing list
http://lists.xiph.org/mailman/listinfo/xiph-rtp

Phil Kerr

2005-10-09 19:47:35 UTC

Permalink

Hi Jean-Marc,

Post by Jean-Marc Valin
Hi Phil,
The speex rtp draft is about to expire and we should re-sumbit it. I
looked at http://www.plus24.com/xiph/draft-ietf-avt-rtp-speex-00.txt and
- Section 7, 2nd paragraph: "Speex codecs [7] are able to detect the the
bitrate from the payload" should remove one "the".

Fixed.

Post by Jean-Marc Valin
- My email is listed (twice) as jean-marc.valin at hermes.usherb.ca. Could
you change it to jean-marc.valin at usherbrooke.ca (the hermes is no longer
valid)

Fixed in both places.

Post by Jean-Marc Valin
- Please are reference to the "penh" parameter. It's doesn't belong to
the RTP draft.

Removed references (commented out in XML).

One other thing I noticed, the first example in Section 9. (SDP) has the
mode set to 4 yet the comment references mode=3. Fixed with mode=4 in
both places.

Also, the ITU page doesn't seem to be on the Speex website yet. This
will need to be fixed before submission.

Post by Jean-Marc Valin
Otherwise, I think we're ready for WG.

Ok.

**** This is *Last Call* for this revision ****

http://www.plus24.com/xiph/draft-ietf-avt-rtp-speex-00.xml
http://www.plus24.com/xiph/draft-ietf-avt-rtp-speex-00.txt

If no calls are made it will be submitted to the IETF on Wednesday 12th
October, 20:00 GMT.

The next IETF meeting has been announced, in Vancouver, with a
provisional AVT slot allocated for 11th November. The WG Chairs have
put a call out for time slot requests and if we want we should let them
know by 24th October. Jean-Marc, would you be able to make this?

Regards

Phil

Post by Jean-Marc Valin
Cheers,
Jean-Marc

Jean-Marc Valin

2005-10-09 23:11:00 UTC

Permalink

Post by Phil Kerr
One other thing I noticed, the first example in Section 9. (SDP) has the
mode set to 4 yet the comment references mode=3. Fixed with mode=4 in
both places.

Good.

Post by Phil Kerr
Also, the ITU page doesn't seem to be on the Speex website yet. This
will need to be fixed before submission.

I wasn't aware that something had to go there. Do you have that
document?

Post by Phil Kerr
The next IETF meeting has been announced, in Vancouver, with a
provisional AVT slot allocated for 11th November. The WG Chairs have
put a call out for time slot requests and if we want we should let them
know by 24th October. Jean-Marc, would you be able to make this?

I think we should check if someone closer can go (I'm in Sydney now).
Ralf maybe?

Jean-Marc

Post by Phil Kerr
Regards
Phil

Post by Jean-Marc Valin
Cheers,
Jean-Marc

_______________________________________________
xiph-rtp mailing list
http://lists.xiph.org/mailman/listinfo/xiph-rtp

Jean-Marc Valin

2005-10-20 20:39:25 UTC

Permalink

Hi Phil,

Was the updated draft submitted? Otherwise, could you do that ASAP?

thanks,

Jean-Marc

Post by Phil Kerr
Hi Jean-Marc,

Fixed.

Post by Jean-Marc Valin
- My email is listed (twice) as jean-marc.valin at hermes.usherb.ca. Could
you change it to jean-marc.valin at usherbrooke.ca (the hermes is no longer
valid)

Fixed in both places.

Post by Jean-Marc Valin
- Please are reference to the "penh" parameter. It's doesn't belong to
the RTP draft.

Removed references (commented out in XML).
One other thing I noticed, the first example in Section 9. (SDP) has the
mode set to 4 yet the comment references mode=3. Fixed with mode=4 in
both places.
Also, the ITU page doesn't seem to be on the Speex website yet. This
will need to be fixed before submission.

Post by Jean-Marc Valin
Otherwise, I think we're ready for WG.

Ok.
**** This is *Last Call* for this revision ****
http://www.plus24.com/xiph/draft-ietf-avt-rtp-speex-00.xml
http://www.plus24.com/xiph/draft-ietf-avt-rtp-speex-00.txt
If no calls are made it will be submitted to the IETF on Wednesday 12th
October, 20:00 GMT.
The next IETF meeting has been announced, in Vancouver, with a
provisional AVT slot allocated for 11th November. The WG Chairs have
put a call out for time slot requests and if we want we should let them
know by 24th October. Jean-Marc, would you be able to make this?
Regards
Phil

Post by Jean-Marc Valin
Cheers,
Jean-Marc